New Jersey Devils Top 25 Prospects 2022-23 Season

This one is really hard to rank. Artem Shlaine was at UConn last season but transferred to Northern Michigan University for this season. He’s centering their second line and has eight goals and six assists through 16 games. That’s second on his team. He scored a power play goal this past weekend against eighth-ranked Minnesota State that started their comeback and led to a major upset. Shlaine is worth paying attention to, but it’s hard to tell where his development goes next.

Jakub Malek could be the biggest Masterclass of the Tom Fitzgerald regime, or he could be a huge reach that backfires. Nobody even considered Malek a draftable goalie prospect in the 2021 NHL Draft. Malek originally started his season with Ilves of Liiga in Finland, but he struggled mightily. He had an .896 save percentage (but only a 2.62 GAA), which wasn’t acceptable for a team trying to compete like Ilves. He was loaned to KOOVIE, which is the second-tier league in Finland. He has dominated there, allowing less than a goal per game in just two games. We’ll see how the rest of the year goes.

Jack Dugan is not a prospect that was always in the system. In fact, he just joined the Devils this year. He was one of the prized prospects in the Vegas Golden Knights system, but something just didn’t click. He signed out of Providence College, where he tore up the NCAA with Tyce Thompson (who will join us later). He was really good in his first professional season, putting up 31 points in 37 games and adding three goals in five playoff games. Then, he fell off a cliff. He had 18 points in 35 games last season with Henderson, and he only has 10 points in 17 games this season. He still clearly has talent, but someone needs to find out how to unlock it.

This one will come off as controversial. Nikita Okhotiuk almost made the Devils out of training camp this season. He was giving a long look for his size, strength, and ability. He can hit, fight, and put fear into opposing skill players. The Devils don’t have a lot of that on the roster. Unfortunately, his skill is pretty limited beyond that. He needs to get better with the puck on his stick if he wants to stay in the NHL for a long period of time. The former second-round pick is really good at stopping the puck, but it’s what comes next that has him so low on this list.

Patrick Moynihan is famous because Ray Shero drafted him in 2019 after Jack Hughes asked him what he thought of him. Moynihan is an interesting prospect, but he’s incredibly flawed. He does a lot of the little things right. Unfortunately, he isn’t scoring a ton. As a winger in the NCAA, that’s a bad sign. However, the Devils like players who can do a little bit of everything. Moynihan needs to do everything right if he’s going to make it to the NHL. He currently only has seven points in 17 games despite a college career best 17% shooting percentage. He needs to do more in the second half of his senior year to prove he can be an NHL prospect.

The University of Michigan is home to three New Jersey Devils defensemen. This is the lowest ranked on this list. Ethan Edwards is on the second line for the now-eight-ranked Wolverines. He’s playing with Seamus Casey. He is probably one of the least talked about Devils strictly because of the team he plays for. He’s literally the third-most likely Michigan defenseman to make the Devils roster. That doesn’t mean he doesn’t have NHL skill. It just means he’s behind two phenomenal players. He’s smaller (5’10), and he isn’t great offensively, but he can skate. Sometimes, that is just enough to get NHL minutes.

Zakhar Bardakov is one of the hardest prospects to rank on this list. There is always one player, usually in the KHL, who starts to put up stats in a men’s league. It’s hard to see when, or if, that will ever translate to the NHL. After playing a full season with SKA St. Petersburg, one of the best teams in the top Russian league, he’s now contributing on a nightly basis. Bardakov’s biggest asset is his compete level. Bardakov is a seventh-round pick, so being named on this chart is impressive enough. However, for some prospect experts to call him a likely NHL player one day is even better. Bardakov has to improve, but he’s shown he’s got the mindset to succeed in this sport.

What a strange journey it’s been for Samy Salminen. He falls on the prospects list after ranking 13th last season. He was supposed to play for the University of Denver, but he faced admissions issues. So, he had to transfer to UConn, but visa issues caused a delay to his season. This really is a nightmare, and the Devils are watching the progress of a great prospect stall. Luckily, he has a really good head on his shoulders. He’s got hockey IQ coming out of everywhere. He was the captain of his Swedish junior team, and after a slow start, he is starting to show up on the score sheet for a surging Huskies team. Salminen could rocket up this list by the end of the year. Just hard to give him the benefit of the doubt without seeing how he reacts to the North American game. We still expect him to be a top-10 prospect eventually.

The Canadian World Juniors rosters were announced, and Tyler Brennan was always a lock to make the team. The fourth-round pick in the most recent NHL Draft has been playing well in the WHL, and many believe he will be the starting goalie for Team Canada once final cuts are announced. It is ironic seeing how Brennan’s season has gone a little sideways. His .884 save percentage is… concerning. However, he has all the tools to be an elite goalie someday. Hopefully, he wins the Canada job outright and can prove himself in this tournament. Gaining a little confidence could help the second half of his season.

Chase Stillman’s name will always take the air out of the room for Devils fans, but he’s actually put up numbers this season. He was the Devils second first-round pick in 2021, taking him with the pick the Devils got in the Kyle Palmieri-Travis Zajac trade. Stillman grabbed headlines after he scored four goals in a game against the Mississauga Steelheads. Outside of that performance, Stillman has been better but not great. He didn’t come close to making Canada’s World Juniors roster. His compete level continues to be his greatest asset. It will be interesting to see where it eventually takes him.

Graeme Clarke is such an interesting prospect. He legitimately got a long look in the preseason, and he was scoring against NHL competition. He finished the preseason with two goals in four games. That’s not nothing! That just hasn’t translated back to the AHL. Clarke is eighth on the team in points with nine. He’s tied for third on the team in goals with four. He was supposed to take a big step forward this season with Alex Holtz graduating to the NHL (which has yet to happen full-time), but he’s failed to fill the hole in the goal-scoring department. There is still a lot to love about Clarke, but this prospect pool is stacked. A prospect can get lost quickly. Clarke has plenty of time to turn it back in his favor. However, he shouldn’t wait too long.

The Devils took a huge chance on Shakir Mukhamadullin at the 2020 NHL Draft, and it looks like he’s been passed up by a plethora of Devils defensive prospects. Mukhamadullin was with the Utica Comets to start the season, but he was loaned back to his KHL team Ufa. We haven’t heard a lot about why, but it seems to be a reason for his growth. He already has his career high for points in a season (13). Mukhamadullin was always a project. He was never going to be NHL-ready in two years. We should revisit the pick in two years to really make a proper analysis.

Josh Filmon is quite the story. He was the Devils most recent sixth-round pick. He was expecting to go in the third round, but he fell down the draft board. Tom Fitzgerald pounced at the chance to take Filmon, who is now using this as motivation (we assume based on his point production). He has 23 points in 20 games to start the season. He’s grown a couple of inches since all the draft stuff happened. He’s now 6’3. Honestly, if he was this tall going into the draft, he might go in the second round. Now, the Devils have this phenomenal asset that came at a rock-bottom price.

Nolan Foote is finally putting together the season we were hoping for since the Devils got him in the Blake Coleman trade. Foote has six goals in 17 games. He’s been one of the few bright spots in a weird Utica season. He’s third on the team in points and second in goals. He looks closer to being an NHL player. Is he someone who’s going to be ripping it up on the Devils soon? No, absolutely not. He does show positive progression, which is all you can ask for at this point.

Of all the prospects in no man’s land, Reilly Walsh tops the list of “what to do next.” He made his NHL debut last season, and he expects to take a leadership role with the Utica Devils this year. So far this season, he has 10 points in 18 games. There is something weird happening in the AHL this season, so his point drop is on par with the rest of the team. Eventually, we expect Walsh to get back to the 43-point pace he had last season. He looks just as good as he did, and there is actually some interesting talent on that team.

Tyce Thompson just has to stay healthy. Every season, it seems like the same thing happens. He almost makes the NHL roster, he gets hurt in training camp, he gets to spend time with the Devils team doctors, then he’s forced to go back to Utica once he’s healthy. Thompson has nine points in 15 games this season. He’s watching his brother Tage become one of the world’s best players. Does that add to the pressure? Luckily, he’s on a Devils team that’s in no rush. He can take his time. However, there are other prospects and future drafts where he could get passed up. For now, Thompson’s future with the franchise is exciting.

Coming into the season, Nico Daws felt like the future of the Devils’ goaltender position. He was the best goalie on the team last season. We’re not talking about Utica. He was the best goalie on the Devils last year. This season, things have started slow. He’s seen his counterpart play insanely well in the NHL, while he’s struggled a little in the AHL. He has a .908 save percentage this season. It’s worse than the .916 save percentage from last season, but his GAA is about the same. If you take out one blowout by Rochester, his season is going really well. Let the season play out, and we expect Daws to be right where he was before.

This is the first time where we get to a tweener prospect who’s basically on the Devils, but it’s close enough to keep him on the prospects list. Kevin Bahl has been really good when given the chance this season. It’s clear his movement is better, he makes better decisions, and he can play at an NHL level. He’s only been in four games so far this season. However, his time practicing with the AHL team has gone a long way. Bahl has grown every season since the Taylor Hall trade. This year, he looks like an official NHL player.

5

Maybe this is recency bias, but Akira Schmid looks like the Devils goalie of the future. At the beginning of the season, he was behind Nico Daws, but he’s been absolutely dominant. He hasn’t only been dominant in the AHL, but he’s been statistically one of the best goalies in the NHL. He is in the lineup while Mackenzie Blackwood recovers from an injury. In his time with the Devils, he won all five games he played (including one he didn’t even start). His .949 save percentage is the best in the league for any goalie who’s played at least four games. Some will think he’s too low and deserves to be in the top five, while others think this is too quick a reaction to put him ahead of Daws. Either way, Schmid might be making Blackwood expendable.

Arseni Gritsyuk had a concerning start to the season, but he’s starting to come into his own. While his point production is down with Avangard, he has a full-time role with the big club at 21 years old. The points are starting to come now that his KHL team is putting him in a position to succeed again. In his past 11 games, he has 10 points. He had 10 points in his first 27 games. If he can get his offensive fire power back, Gritsyuk could get a look in the NHL sooner rather than later.

The Devils got incredibly lucky in this year’s NHL Draft. Seamus Casey was a player a lot of analysts liked a lot. Some even thought he should go in the middle of the first round. Instead, the Devils got Casey with the 46th-overall pick. He has 16 points in 18 games for the University of Michigan. The main issue for Casey is size. He’s 5’9. If Casey was even 6’0, he would easily be a first rounder. His skills look like they will translate to the next level. They are helping him overcome the size issue, and it has him rocketed up to the top five in the Devils prospect rankings.

Alex Holtz was expected to graduate into the NHL this season. He was really good in the AHL last season, and it seemed like it would be a natural progression to the big leagues. He really dominated at the start of the preseason with Ondrej Palat and Jack Hughes, but an issue with speed kept him off that line and out of the lineup in general. After an injury to Nathan Bastian, Holtz finds himself back into the lineup. This time, he’s playing with Jesper Boqvist and Yegor Sharangovich. Listen, he’s still an incredible shooter. He should be a 30-goal player at some point in his career. For now, he needs to work on the little things before they become big problems. We should still be incredibly excited to have him as part of this franchise.

The top three prospects for the Devils are clear. Holtz, Simon Nemec, and Luke Hughes are incredible players. The order doesn’t necessarily matter, because they all project to be great players. Nemec was the second-overall pick in this year’s draft. After playing well in the Slovak men’s league, Nemec jumped straight into a North American professional league. We shouldn’t say he’s struggling, because there are moments where he looks dominant with the puck. He just hasn’t had consistency on the offensive end of things. He’s an 18-year-old defenseman playing in the AHL. It might take a year or two, but the Devils are going to build the blue line around him and the next player eventually.

The top player in the Devils system is Luke Hughes. He’s gotten better every single season, he’s build like a brick house, he has intense offensive skills, and he’s taken on a leadership role with the Wolverines. Many expected his numbers to drop off after Michigan lost a plethora of incredible players, including Owen Power, Kent Johnson, Matty Berniers, and others. Luckily, they added Adam Fantilli, who is likely going to go in the top three of this year’s draft. He is replacing a lot of the offense and is keeping Michigan in the top 10 in the NCAA. They are still a contender for a national championship. If Hughes can take this team further than Power and the star-studded team of last year could, then it will increase his star power. He also gets to lead Team USA at World Juniors over the next few weeks. There’s a lot to love about Hughes, and the Devils seem to be in an incredible position thanks to their defensive prospects.