The New Jersey Devils had a defensible plan for Connor Hellebuyck’s return to Winnipeg. It involves a press conference in the day to get the headlines out of the way. The way they announced it is the problem.
This takes this Devils fan back to the days of Zach Parise. When the Devils’ captain left following a trip to the Stanley Cup Final, there was obviously animosity. Then, Devils fans had to wait. A lockout caused Parise’s first matchup with his first team to wait another year. He left on July 4, 2012, and didn’t return to New Jersey until March 20, 2014.
But that wasn’t Parise’s or their GM’s decision. That was the league schedule maker’s.
Hellebuyck is not a normal visiting goalie in Winnipeg. The three-time Vezina winner publicly demanded a trade, and the Jets suspended him for failing to report to training camp. The Jets finally sent him to New Jersey for Dawson Mercer, Nico Daws, Nick Bjugstad, and draft picks.
He later wrote to fans that “very challenging circumstances” involving his family were part of the decision. Jets fans have waited weeks for Tuesday, and Hellebuyck has said he will explain his exit when he speaks that morning.
That’s all well and good, but it’s not really “facing the music,” as he put it. He seems to understand what’s on the line here. Sunny Mehta needs to, as well.
The New Jersey Devils had no business releasing a statement on Connor Hellebuyck's start decision
Sitting him is easy to understand. He played on Sunday night, the Devils have two games against the Capitals this week, and Jake Allen will start in his place. Head coach Sheldon Keefe framed it as workload management after Sunday’s win. “You’re always looking for times to give him a night off,” he said. Protecting a goalie who is 5-0 with his new team is hardly controversial.
The Devils didn’t just rest him. They issued a statement from general manager Sunny Mehta saying Hellebuyck “was adamant that he felt a duty to play” and that playing would reduce the team’s “expected win probability.” Hellebuyck is already scheduled to face reporters Tuesday morning. The Devils could have let him address the decision there, alongside everything else he plans to say.
Instead, the statement landed right after his first shutout as a Devil, a 23-save, 4-0 win over Toronto that made him the first goalie in franchise history to win his first five games with the club. The story should have been a dominant performance. It became the benching.
It also muddies who is making the call. Keefe pointed to rest, while the front office pointed to analytics and made it clear the player wanted to start. Hellebuyck himself said, “I’m disappointed, but I understand,” and added that “it’s out of my hands.” A GM statement, a coach talking load management, and a player saying the decision wasn’t his make it look like the choice was taken away from anyone while hiding behind the veil of analytics.
By releasing a formal statement, the Devils turned a routine night off into a referendum on whether he was held back or ducked the moment. A quiet update Tuesday would have drawn a fraction of the attention. Instead, New Jersey made its goalie’s absence the biggest story in the building before he ever got to Winnipeg.
Add us as a preferred source on Google