Skip to main content

Voters should break tradition in the name of Sunny Mehta

There is a legitimate argument for Sunny Mehta to be considered an early frontrunner for the Jim Gregory Award.
ByJP Gambatese
Nov 18, 2026; Newark, New Jersey, USA;  New Jersey Devils right wing Luke Evangelista (77) celebrates  with center Nico Hischier (13) after scoring a goal during the first period against the Montreal Canadiens at Prudential Center.  Mandatory Credit: Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images
Nov 18, 2026; Newark, New Jersey, USA; New Jersey Devils right wing Luke Evangelista (77) celebrates with center Nico Hischier (13) after scoring a goal during the first period against the Montreal Canadiens at Prudential Center. Mandatory Credit: Vincent Carchietta-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

In the midst of the NHL playoffs every season, the league announces the winner of the Jim Gregory Award, which signifies who voters believe to be the "General Manager of the Year." All in all, 42 people vote on the award -- all 32 NHL GMs, in addition to five NHL executives and five media members.

As one could imagine, as is with many other aspects of the game, the vote seems to center around the old boys' club that is the NHL. Year after year, the same names seem to be recycled in the voting regardless of whatever success other teams have. Or, at least, the same motif of Hockey Men being at the forefront of whatever voting takes place. Last season, Bill Guerin won the award, besting finalists Pat Verbeek (longtime NHLer) and Chris MacFarland (who has been in and around the NHL for nearly 35 years). Prior to that, ex-NHLer Jim Nill won three consecutive Jim Gregory Awards. Before him, it was Joe Sakic, and before him, Lou Lamoriello won back-to-back.

As you continue to go down the list, one thing becomes increasingly clear: new-wave General Managers do not get the respect they deserve among the voters, regardless of how successful or "respected" they are. Eric Tulsky, GM of the team that just won the Stanley Cup, who has done nothing but make the right moves time after time, has never been a finalist. He finished sixth in voting in 2026.

More often than not, the names at the top are consistently Hockey Men. Really, the only exception is Bill Zito, who never played in the NHL, nor has he been around for 20-plus years. He was voted a finalist on four separate occasions, but has never actually won the award.

Rookie GMs are scarcely looked upon as being worthy of votes, too. The closest rookie ever to win was Zito himself, who placed third after the 2020-21 season.

Enter Sunny Mehta, who is already one of the most respected GMs in the league despite not yet owning the position for eight months.

Mehta checks neither box; he is perhaps the second-furthest thing from a Hockey Man GM behind Tulsky, and he has only really been an executive since the 2014-15 season, when he helped establish the first official analytics department in the NHL. Seven months and a few days into his tenure, though, he is already deserving of being the frontrunner for the award, regardless of whether or not he fits the bill of a traditional recipient.

In just one off-season, Mehta's moves have turned the New Jersey Devils from a perennial disappointment relative to expectations into a legit contender. They've gotten off to a blistering 15-7-0 start and, unlike years prior with hot starts, the Devils have the underlying metrics to back up their dominance.

Sunny Mehta had an uphill climb when he took the Devils top job

He undid Tom Fitzgerald's blunders, shipping Jacob Markstrom to the Florida Panthers for a pair of useful everyday players and ensuring Dougie Hamilton would stay in black and red while capitalizing on Simon Nemec's inflated value. He went out and acquired the biggest fish on the market, solving the Devils' goaltending woes with Connor Hellebuyck, who just yesterday lost his first game in a Devils sweater. He made a big swing for Luke Evangelista, one of New Jersey's best players in both process and production. He made smart, value-forward bets in Declan Chisholm and Amadeus Lombardi. He completely redid the entire front office from the top down.

All the while, he has spearheaded the Utica Comets' resurgence, putting a focus on improving the AHL team that has been a laughingstock for a number of years. Through Mehta and Braden Birch (whom Mehta brought in), the Comets are enjoying one of the fastest starts in recent memory, playing to the tune of a 10-3-0 record.

Really, there is no reason Mehta shouldn't be the frontrunner for the Jim Gregory Award, outside of not being the prototypical candidate. Even if you're outside of the Devils' sphere, there is simply no denying the positive impact he has had on this organization in such a short span of time.

Add us as a preferred source on Google