Skip to main content

When is the right time to be concerned about Connor Hellebuyck's performance?

Connor Hellebuyck has allowed a few too many soft goals recently, and his all-time worst performance on Saturday night did not do much to curry favor in his direction.
ByNick Villano
New Jersey Devils goaltender Connor Hellebuyck (37) makes a save: Daniel Kucin Jr.-Imagn Images
New Jersey Devils goaltender Connor Hellebuyck (37) makes a save: Daniel Kucin Jr.-Imagn Images | IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

.333. That was the save percentage of Connor Hellebuyck on Saturday night against the St. Louis Blues. He allowed four goals on six shots against. It was a dreadful performance, obviously, and it turned a six-goal Devils performance into a loss. A bad one at that, where they allowed nine total goals against. 

Last season, Hellebuyck had a dreadful performance where he allowed six goals against the New York Rangers. It was his worst single-game save percentage of his career. That was a .688. This was more than twice as bad as that one. 

The Devils sent a package of their 12th-overall pick from this year, Alexander Command, Dawson Mercer, Nico Daws, and two draft picks for Hellebuyck. He won his first seven games with the Devils, skipped out on the Jets game to cause a major firestorm, and has now lost his last two. 

This wasn’t the Hellebuyck the Devils expected, and that’s okay for now. If Hellebuyck is still an elite goalie who needs time to ramp up, then the price of acquisition won’t matter. However, that’s not what he was last season. He was pretty average. 

And now, all the good fortune he had to start his Devils career is kind of out the window. He allowed four goals on six shots on Saturday night, and the game-winning goal for the Montreal Canadiens on Wednesday went off his glove. He admitted he should have had that one. 

With now two consecutive examples of less desirable performances, Hellebuyck is at a little bit of a crossroads. We can’t blame rest this time. The Devils only played two games this week.

Luckily, the Devils built enough of a cushion that two losses won’t kill them. They play four games next week. The opponents are relatively weak (Calgary, Winnipeg, and Columbus x2), and the Devils are three points ahead of the Rangers and Islanders for second in the Metropolitan Division. 

So, when should Devils fans start to worry about Connor Hellebuyck?

Going back to the original question, the time to worry about Hellebuyck should theoretically be far away, but the Devils have to continue seriously outplaying their opponents while he figures a few things out. The penalty kill is a disaster, so they just need to stay out of the box. They have to keep the offense up and limit chances. 

If Hellebuyck looks like this for the next two weeks, where he’s allowing bad goals and his goals-saved above-average is in the negative, then there should be some worry. The Islanders aren’t going away, which is closing the Devils' cushion in the Metro. As much as we want to believe this is an elite team, Saturday night hit the brakes on any thought of that for now. 

Until Hellebuyck completely flames out again, it’s easy to say we can burn the tape from Saturday. 

Add us as a preferred source on Google